EnvyThe second deadly sin

You see exactly what everyone else has.

Envy is sorrow at another’s good fortune. It sharpens your ambition and your eye for detail — and quietly poisons the joy of what you already have.

i. The nature of the sin

What is the sin of envy?

Envy is the only deadly sin that is no fun at all. Pride gets the throne and gluttony gets the feast; envy only gets to watch. Thomas Aquinas defined it as sorrow at another’s good — the small, private sting when a friend’s news lands a little too well.

If envy leads your profile, you are perceptive, ambitious and acutely aware of where you stand. You notice what others miss, including the gap between their lives and yours. That awareness can drive you to extraordinary effort — or trap you in a comparison no achievement ever settles, because there is always someone further ahead.

“It is the green-ey’d monster which doth mock the meat it feeds on.”

— Shakespeare, Othello

ii. Light & shadow

Every vice is a virtue that forgot its limits

The gift

  • A sharp eye for quality and detail
  • Ambition that turns longing into effort
  • A deep understanding of what people really want

The shadow

  • Comparison that turns every win into a loss
  • Struggling to celebrate friends without a sting
  • A private bitterness that is hard to name

iii. The signs

Signs that envy rules you

  1. I

    You check how an old rival is doing — often

  2. II

    A friend’s good news leaves a flicker of something sour

  3. III

    You put other people’s success down to luck or connections

  4. IV

    You know precisely who is “ahead” of you

iv. In your life

How envy shows up

In love

You may quietly fear that the person you love will find someone better. Security grows when you stop auditioning against imaginary rivals.

At work

Competition brings out your best work. The trap is working to beat someone rather than to build something — that finish line keeps moving.

v. The penance of Dante

Terrace II of Mount Purgatory

Terrace IIEnvy
Dante’s Mount Purgatory: seven terraces, one for each sin — the gravest at the foot, the lightest nearest heaven.

On the second terrace, the envious sit in cloaks of grey haircloth, leaning on one another, their eyelids stitched shut with iron wire — eyes that once watched others with resentment, now closed to the world.

vi. The remedy

The cure is kindness

Humanitas

Wanting good things for others as easily as you want them for yourself.

  1. Penance I

    Congratulate someone you envy — sincerely and specifically.

  2. Penance II

    Mute the accounts that make you feel smaller, for one month.

  3. Penance III

    Write down three things you have that someone else would envy.

vii. Kindred spirits

You are in storied company

  • Genesis

    Cain

    Killed his brother because his offering was favoured.

  • Shakespeare, Othello

    Iago

    Destroys a general out of resentment he never fully explains.

  • Grimm, Snow White

    The Queen

    Asked the mirror who was fairest — and could not bear the answer.

Latin
Invidia
Virtue
Kindness · Humanitas
Demon
Leviathan
Animal
Serpent
Colour
Green
Terrace
II of VII

Know thyself

Is envy your sin — or only your second?

Take the test